Superyacht Skipper Can Pursue Unfair Dismissal Claim in England

Superyacht Skipper Can Pursue Unfair Dismissal Claim in England

The limited territorial reach of English Employment Tribunals can pose difficulties to those who lead globe-trotting working lives. In a guideline case, however, the former captain of a superyacht which moved from port to port won the right to pursue his unfair dismissal claim in this country.

The captain launched proceedings before an Employment Tribunal in London after he was sacked for alleged gross misconduct. His employer, a Guernsey-based company that provides crews for luxury yachts, argued that the case had almost no connection to England and there was no jurisdiction to consider the matter. That issue was considered at a preliminary hearing.

The Tribunal noted that the yacht was registered in the Cayman Islands and owned by a company that was based there. Although a British citizen, the captain was resident in Florida, received his salary in euros and paid his taxes in the US. During his captaincy, the yacht had sailed widely, visiting a number of Caribbean ports.

The Tribunal accepted that the captain’s place of work was wherever the yacht happened to be at any one time and that the UK could not be viewed as his home base. On the other side of the balance, however, was evidence that the yacht had spent about half of the relevant period in UK waters, more than in any other jurisdiction, and that she was berthed in England on the date of his dismissal.

Ruling in the captain’s favour, the Tribunal also noted that he had been recruited and promoted in England by an English-resident businessman. The latter, whilst not his employer and whilst having no legal title to the yacht, was the vessel’s effective owner. Although an array of entities was apparently involved in running the yacht, the businessman acted as her paymaster and exercised control by issuing instructions to the captain from his home in the UK. In those circumstances, the Tribunal found that it had jurisdiction to entertain the captain’s claim.

COVID-19 Information

We are OPEN and would like to reassure our client's that it is business as usual and as a firm we intend on supporting our clients through this difficult time. Please note: Clients are requested to wear face masks when attending our office(s). As a precautionary measure to limit the risk to everyone our preferred communication is by telephone and/or email and/or post. We may take a little longer to respond to enquiries and deal with matters. Please bear with us in these unprecedented times.